Difference between outsourcing and offshoring with. Many offshoring companies operate within a 512 hour difference from their client. First, researchers have attempted to understand the strategic intent behind outsourcing and offshoring and the determinants in such decisions. The most common story of outsourcing in the news today involves jobs that are sent overseas to countries like india or chinaoften manufacturing jobs, but outsourcing is not limited to this sector. Outsourcing and offshoring information system projects. Outsourcing and offshoring information system projects 351 offshore outsourcing of information systems services has been growing rapidly in recent years and is likely to continue into the foreseeable future. Rethinking the model for offshoring services mckinsey. North american airlines engine and heavy maintenance outsourcing source. Its possible to outsource work but not offshore it. To fill this empirical gap, one needs access to a large matched employeremployee panel, as. The opposing sides regarding offshoring, outsourcing, and offshore outsourcing are those seeking government intervention and protectionism versus the side advocating free trade. More recently, technical and administrative services have been offshored. Disadvantages of offshoring jobs time zone differences. Understanding this model enables a company to seek locations for offshoring in a region or town that will grow in conjunction with their presence in the area.
Offshoring, outsourcing, and strategy in the global firm. The outsourcing can be domestic or carried out in another country. The handbook of global outsourcing and offshoring 3rd edition oshri, ilan, kotlarsky, julia, willcocks, leslie p. Yet there is much out left in sourcing, and even more off ahead of us in shoring. Globalization, offshoring and jobs chapter 1 holger gorg 1 21 1. One of the biggest disadvantages of offshoring is the time zone differences.
Offshoring vs outsourcing difference and comparison diffen. I conclude from this that offshoring brings remarkable opportunities to us all. The operational risk of offshoring and outsourcing these processes is very low. You can find the important differences between outsourcing and offshoring below. Global offshoring trends offshoring and outsourcing services the globalization of service offshoring and outsourcing begun to take off in late 1990s. Several authors have documented the increasing prevalence of domestic outsourcing in the united states. This often involves the transfer of process, people and assets to the supplier. This was the dominant strategy for maximizing value in the global manufacturing supply chain during the 1970s and 1980s. The global relocation of pharmaceutical industry clinical trials by pooja thakur a dissertation submitted to the graduate school newark rutgers, the state university of new jersey in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy ph. In todays globalized economy, firms often consider offshoring when confronted by rising costs and fierce competition.
Based on our survey, we propose recommendations for public policy and reforms that we think will help ease this transition from a national economy to a world economy and from a world of inhouse production to a world of outsourcing. May 19, 2017 outsourcing is performed by nonemployees, but offshoring is performed by employees of the business entity. Offshore outsourcing is the practice of hiring a vendor to do the work offshore, usually to lower costs and take advantage of the vendors expertise, economies of scale, and large and scalable labor pool. International outsourcing is defined as the purchase by a company of services or material inputs from a source located in another country. The primary reason behind this trend is the apparent economic cost advantages gained by offshore service procurement. Pdf outsourcing, offshoring outsourcing and offshoring. Introduction outsourcing andor offshoring is one of the important and key strategic approaches in complex, dynamic and competitive global supply chains.
Outsourcing vs offshoring top 7 amazing differences with. Outsourcing technology services ffiec it examination. Page 7 of 19 offshoring refers to outsourcing done overseas, across national borders. Globalization and offshoring or offshoring outsourcing presents various benefits to different business but bring new problems concerning especially supply chain issues. Countries such as china and india are popular offshoring locations. Typically, offshoring of the production of material goods is better for higher. What has truly been driving the debate of offshoring has been the fact that none of these jobs has benefited unemployed us it laborers even though almost all of the parent companies using offshore labor are based in the us. Global outsourcing and offshoring chapter 1 global. The topic of offshore outsourcing is as much a political topic as an economic one, and perhaps even more so.
The handbook of global outsourcing and offshoring 3rd. Work schedules may need to be adjusted to accommodate time zone differences when working with offshore companies. The outsourcing handbook a guide to outsourcing version 2. Outsourcing and offshoring decision making article pdf available in international journal of production research 57. The presentation of the business process offshoringoutsourcing decision has devolved into a 2x2 matrix, contrasting inoutsourcing with onoffshoring see fig. Offshoring is a strategic tool used by organisations to reconfigure their activities across geographic locations the focus and trend has traditionally been on information technology and manufacturing, however it is now a common strategy for many organisations in the services sector. Outsourcing, offshoring outsourcing and offshoring article pdf available in cesifo forum 52. Unlike outsourcing, offshoring is primarily a geographic activity. It is one of the best processes to offer support for the processes, accounting, manufacturing. When considering the offshore outsourcing dilemma from a macro level, the unemployment problem does not look as negative. Pdf the handbook of global outsourcing and offshoring.
Offshore company businesses now become an order of the day. Companies have some ability to measure the quality of execution and can codify most of the work. For example, abraham and taylor 1996 analyzed a survey question on outsourcing in the 19791987 industry wage surveys and found an increase in the. The presentation of the business process offshoring outsourcing decision has devolved into a 2x2 matrix, contrasting in outsourcing with on offshoring see fig. Examples include customer service and tech support call center jobs, as well as computer programming jobs. As this shows, the outsourcing market is growing in. Forrester research considers offshoring the production. Contents introduction 4 provides a brief overview of what outsourcing is, and describes deloittes.
The publication has benefited from the experience of people who were interviewed. In addition, offshoring, due to the overseas specificity of outsourcing, has the following. This is certainly a major improvement on the fiveyearago discussion that commonly confused where an activity was happening with who was doing it, but it reflects a disregard for. In the following chapter, the terms offshoring, outsourcing and offshore outsourcing are defined. This research attempts to build on this stream of research to guide managers in the decisionmaking process of where in the world does it. Outsourcing can also involve offshoring as well as significant transformation, for instance where. Offshoring is when a business relocates or moves part of its operations to a country different from the one it currently operates in. This can occur domestically or in an offshoring situation. The continuous development of outsourcing and offshoring and the associated advantages and disadvantages with them can be a factor in the competitiveness of modern business at regional, national and global level. Decision must be made taking into acc ount both benefits and other considerations. While much offshoring involves outsourcing production to another company it can also refer to simply relocation certain aspects of a business to another country.
Outsourcing and offshoring are commonplace terms, but theyre often poorly understood and inexpertly practiced. Whenever your company outsources a specific task to offshore, language and culture appears to be crucial hurdles for successful execution of the project. Teamsai consulting services, outsourcing trends in the usa, november 2009. Internal outsourcing is the purchase by a company of services or material inputs from a source located in another firm within the same country. Outsourcing when deciding between offshoring or outsourcing there are many factors that need to be considered, and the right decision will vary from company to company. Offshoring and outsourcing advantages and disadvantages. We therefore begin by discussing the politics, as seen through the eyes of economists working at the white house during an election year. Valuable inputs have been received from vlasta macku, michiko enomoto and cora mezger. Fourth, offshoring is an umbrella term used to describe a variety of different activities, with different impacts. In the west, goods are expensive because the staff required to produce and distribute them are costly. While insourcing lets you have more control, allows your employees to feel more ownership, and allows you to have more customization and flexibility for quick changes. The evolution of a rapidly growing mode of offshoring, captive centers. Using outsourcing and even offshoring activities for a call center is in vogue since last decade. Although, in offshoring, the shifting of business to another country is a must.
One mode of offshoring has continued to grow despite the current global economic turmoil. Outsourcing work to an organization that subsequently outsources the work to a company in another country is referred to as the global delivery model. It is one of the sustained trends of business undertaken by the. Ultimately there can be significant cost savings or specialization benefits from both offshoring and outsourcing, which is what drives many companies to choose. Outside resourcing is also renowned as subcontracting, and it is a process whereby the business or the firms or the organizations will delegate or transfer their peripheral or noncore activities to the external firms or the organizations i. The handbook of global outsourcing and offshoring 3rd edition. Jul 28, 2017 unlike outsourcing, offshoring is primarily a geographic activity. Implications for domestic jobs and aviation safety congressional research service 4 figure 3. Outsourcing is when a company contracts with another company to do some work for another. Third, offshoring has different effects on different groups.
Definition, pros and cons, examples, offshoring companies, howto. This book is an intelligent users manual essential reading for those starting out as well as those who find they may have strayed off course. Typically, lowskill workers are harmed by offshoring, while highskill workers benefit. From these considerations we can remember poor alignment of objectives, response time and quality, with control by various methods pre. The information technology examination handbook infobase concept was developed by the task force on examiner education to provide field examiners in financial institution regulatory agencies with a quick source of introductory training and basic information. Outsourcing may be performed within or outside the country. Typically this refers to a company business, although state governments may also employ offshoring.
Now in its third edition, this is the only outsourcing and offshoring book to offer a broad but coherent guide to the strategy, operations and management of ito and bpo outsourcing and offshoring, from how to source new relationships to managing business processes in a national and global context. Outsourcing advantages and disadvantages you will find that in the insource vs outsource debate, positives and negatives are inverses of one another. Outsourcing vs offshoring top 7 amazing differences. Outsourcing refers to an organization contracting work out to a 3rd party, while offshoring refers to getting work done in a different country, usually to leverage cost advantages. Outside resourcing is also renowned as subcontracting, and it is a process whereby the business or the firms or the organizations will delegate or transfer their peripheral or noncore activities to the external firms or. The longterm goal of the infobase is to provide justintime training for new regulations and for other topics of specific concern to. The terms outsourcing and offshoring are often used almost synonymously. The outsourcing and offshoring industry is at a turning point. The line of demarcation between the two is subtle, but they are different terms. Presentations 1 documents 0 infographics 0 videos 0.
10 558 737 905 1082 339 108 1150 706 489 850 1598 1588 607 427 889 630 1205 1258 118 1108 1239 564 1050 1122 1104 768 1295 970 289 264 1467 982 332 742 345 1168 394 840 209 277 430 1071 1238 21 1389